The Twin Towers (Continued)
The second tower of humanity's distinctiveness is our ability to
love. Our altruism poses one of the most difficult challenges to
the doctrine of selfish genes. But, however science eventually explains
such behaviour, it remains a uniquely human and strangely powerful
characteristic. When love is turned outwards beyond our immediate
families it becomes still harder to rationalise; but when it happens,
it produces effects that reach miles and years beyond the original
acts. From old times we have heard it said that when someone hits
you, you should hit him back, giving black eye for black eye and
broken tooth for broken tooth. Turning the other cheek does not
sound a good survival tactic, but it is a powerful way to change
minds. Militarism never won the Cold War; instead, ordinary human
need, diplomatic cooperation and open-hearted generosity toppled
walls and watchtowers.
If the western world were to foment itself to hatred, seeking revenge
on ill-defined enemies, it would pull down the twin towers of wisdom
and love and put us on the level of wild animals. The outcome of
military vengeance would confirm evil men in their misguided beliefs
and persuade others to move inwards from the fringe and become terrorists
themselves. Where a hundred fanatics are destroyed a thousand will
take their place. There is a natural and appropriate desire for
justice, but revenge is dangerous. Revenge is wild
and irrational, but justice is precise and considered. Our most
desirable objective is to change minds, which would be fanned into
stronger hatred by the wind of revenge, but may be melted into cooperation
by the warmth of love.
How could we possibly love people who can turn civilian planes
carrying innocent citizens into lethal weapons of mass destruction?
That is not the point. Terrorism is a minority force, measured in
tens and hundreds rather than millions; but it will bloom from smoking
ruins if we allow hatred to take root. Our love target is the millions
of people whose desperation and fear makes them believe the hotheads
and give them sympathy and support. If we clothe and feed refugees
and oppressed peoples we make it harder for them to hate us. If
we crush and punish the poverty-stricken masses we will give the
extremists evidence to support their propaganda.
The most likely outcome of the terrorist attacks on New York's
Twin Towers was that animal hatred would wreak revenge and feed
the fires of terrorism. The most noble, the most creative and the
most distinctively human response would be to raise the twin towers
of wisdom and love and respond so creatively that terror is stopped
in its tracks.
© Derrick
Phillips
17 September 2001
POSTSCRIPT (September 2002)
The attacks of September 11th 2001 presented a unique challenge
to anyone seeking to predict the future. One year on, it is gratifying
to see how restrained the West has been in its reaction. Wisdom
seems to have prevailed and, perhaps, we have shown ourselves to
be more grown-up than we could have hoped. But hatred is still in
the world and we cannot afford to naively return to our parichial
preoccupations. Whilst looking back at the horrors of last year,
we must keep focused on the current needs of those regions of the
world that nurture our greatest threats.To hold back the tide of
hatred we need to generate counter-forces of hope that will deny
terrorism its supply of disillusioned and embittered recruits.
© Derrick
Phillips
2 September 2002
|